Skip to main content

Reading Group Guide

Discussion Questions

Vanishing Acts

1. A recurrent theme in Vanishing Acts is self-identity. Are we products of our pasts, or do we have more control over whom we become?

2. How important is it to be aware of our pasts, and in what ways?

3. Before we know why Andrew kidnapped Delia, he says, page 52: "By now you've already formed your own impression. You believe that an act committed a lifetime ago defines a man, or you believe that a person's past has nothing to do with his future. You think I am either a hero, or a monster." What was your feeling about him before knowing his reasons for what he did?

4. Did you change your opinion about Andrew's actions after his reasons were revealed?

5. Andrew says, "Believe what you want, but be prepared to answer this question: In my shoes, how do you know you wouldn't have done the same thing?" Would you have done the same thing? If you feel that what Andrew did was wrong, what would have been a more appropriate alternative to ensure Delia's best interests?

6. Delia says on page 151: "Sometimes knowing what's right isn't a rational decision, or even what works on paper. Sometimes leaving is the best course of action after all." Do you agree or disagree? Is doing the wrong thing EVER the right thing? Are there are ever circumstances that justify breaking the law?

7. In what way does Delia's romantic relationship with Fitz, while engaged to Eric, parallel Andrew's decision to kidnap Delia?

8. After Delia learns why Andrew kidnapped her, she suddenly recovers some important childhood memories which support Andrew's claims. Did you feel her memories were accurate, or did you think that these memories were created in her mind because she wanted to see her father acquitted? What evidence in the book supports your belief?

9. In what ways does Elise's alcoholism significantly impact both Delia and Eric, and the choices that they ultimately make? In what ways do the ways Delia and Andrew choose to deal with an alcoholic partner deal with that person's future success or failure? Had they acted differently, do you think Elise and Eric might have had different outcomes?

10. Through RuthAnn, Delia is introduced to the Hopi belief system that we are currently on our fourth world, about to enter our fifth - and that when a world no longer fits you can move into a new one. How does this apply to the other characters in the book?

11. Delia, page 279: "I wonder if the mother eagle will come back to the village now, and see that her offspring is missing. I think maybe she won't. I think maybe she knows to look for him in better places." Might Elise have had Delia's best interests at heart in not trying harder to find her?

12. Andrew, Eric and Fitz have all been keeping secrets from Delia in an attempt to spare her any pain. Were any of them justified in doing so? Are there circumstances when it's acceptable to withhold the truth from those we love, and how do we know where to draw the line?

Vanishing Acts
by Jodi Picoult

  • Publication Date: November 15, 2005
  • Genres: Fiction
  • Paperback: 448 pages
  • Publisher: Washington Square Press
  • ISBN-10: 0743454553
  • ISBN-13: 9780743454551