Skip to main content

Reading Group Guide

Discussion Questions


1. Discuss the novel’s title. What are the many costs --- emotional and material --- associated with Jack’s addiction? What other circumstances lead the characters to consider their self-worth, or the “worth” of others?

2. How does Julia’s relationship with her sister compare with Steven’s relationship with his brother? What leads siblings to become estranged despite having been close during childhood?

3. What does the house in Maine represent to Julia at various points in her life? How does the house set the tone for the novel: picturesque, laden with memories, and in need of repair?

4. What does Cost tell us about the nature of marriage? What enabled Edward and Katharine to sustain their marriage? How does Wendell justify his affair? Is Harriet wise to avoid marriage, pursuing long-term relationships instead?

5. What are the repercussions of the parenting styles presented in the novel? Was Julia harmed by Edward’s judgmental nature? To what extent was Jack’s life a response to the way he perceived his parents?

6. Does Carpenter change Julia’s family, or are they unaffected by his talk of loving interactions? What is captured in the moment when Edward mentally corrects Carpenter, asserting that addiction is not an illness (chapter twenty-seven)? Does Edward have different standards for the ill? Where does he believe self-determination ends and nature begins?

7. Steven is haunted by his parents’ infidelity. Why does he blame his mother more easily than his father? How do Julia’s memories of Eric shape the way she sees herself?

8. What accounts for the difference between Jack and Steven, who uses his rebellion for noble causes (such as protesting against loggers)? Would Steven have been an achiever if his brother had not been so troubled?

9. What portraits of the mind are offered in Cost? How does Edward feel about his memories of being a pioneering surgeon? What remains of Katherine despite her fading memory? What realities does each character create in the face of a disorienting world?

10. In chapter thirty-two, Julia tells Jack that he has to try harder. Is Julia naïve or simply afraid of what lies in store for her son? How do the other members of the family respond to both the psychological and the neurological fallout of his addiction? Why is it easier for Julia to acknowledge her parents’ faltering health, while Harriet wants to believe that they are just fine?

11. What aspects of Julia’s life emerge during her gallery opening? What is the significance of Harriet’s presence there?

12. What were you thinking as you read the novel’s closing scenes? Which characters had changed the most, along with your impressions of them?

13. How would you and your family have responded to a situation like Jack’s? What do you believe can or should be done to address the needs of those with such severe addictions?

14. What themes are woven throughout this and other novels and stories by Roxana Robinson? What is unique about the approach she uses in bringing Julia’s situation to life?

by Roxana Robinson

  • Publication Date: May 26, 2009
  • Paperback: 448 pages
  • Publisher: Picador
  • ISBN-10: 0312428464
  • ISBN-13: 9780312428464