1. What does THE SHATTERED TREE in the opening pages represent?

2. Discuss the role of the British Army and their medical services stationed in France during World War I. How do they treat non-British soldiers?

3. Why did the Scottish patient attack the French patient? What underlying factors may have played into this?

4. Historical reference is made to the Franco-Prussian War and the imperial territory of Alsace-Lorraine created by the German Empire. Discuss how this historical context plays into the depiction of France and Germany in WWI and within THE SHATTERED TREE.

5. THE SHATTERED TREE begins one month prior to the end of WWI. Describe elements in the narrative that portray the coming resolution to this conflict.

6. Describe Bess Crawford's relationship with Simon. He has been a pivotal character in this series. What role does he play in THE SHATTERED TREE, and what does he represent for Bess?

7. Discuss the impact of Bess' injury and how it changes the story. How does it make her better understand the role of a patient during wartime?

8. What role do Allied deserters play in this novel? What do you think is the appropriate justice for these people?

9. THE SHATTERED TREE of the title lies in No Man's Land. Discuss the significance and symbolism of this.

10. Who is Philippe Moreau, and in what way does he affect this story?

11. What is the relationship between Philippe Moreau and Jerome Karades? How is Bess involved with these two men?

12. Discuss the importance of the lacquer box that belongs to Sister Marie-Luc.

13. What is the history between Paul and Philippe Moreau, and how does it impact the action in THE SHATTERED TREE?

14. In a time of war, it's extremely difficult to maintain a sense of civility and justice. How does Bess play a role in assisting justice to triumph in the face of madness?