1. The novel begins with Therese and Maeve having a rocky relationship. How does their relationship develop and change over the course of the novel?

2. Therese and Maeve are sent to Ireland by their mother, in the hope that they would figure out more about their family history and get closer as sisters. Do you think it worked? If so, do you think it’s because of the trip or another reason?

3. Maeve and Therese’s family history drives their story in the novel. What role do you think past family history plays in your life today?

4. Therese is originally characterized quite negatively. How does her character change throughout the novel? Why?

5. The text often inserts old letters from Kathleen to her brother, Tommy. What role do these old letters play in the story? How does the author use these letters to weave past and present together?

6. Kathleen’s story of moving to the United States is shown and described in great detail. How does the novel show the immigrant experience? How does being a descendant of an immigrant change someone’s perspective on the world and their own family history?

7. To Maeve, being in Ireland is like wearing a pair of shoes that is already broken in. Is returning to your ancestor’s homeland necessary to connect with them, or are there other ways to engage with their history and story?

8. What did you think about the ending? Did you find it satisfying? Were there any parts of it you found to be upsetting?

9. Throughout the course of the novel, both sisters have romantic encounters. What did you think about the development of the two romantic relationships? Which one did you root for more?

10. Esme is shown in a negative light until near the end of the novel. What are your thoughts on Esme and her unlikely friendship toward the end of the book?