1. In the course of this novel, Manon Gaudet moves from adoring her dead father to rejecting him so fiercely that she turns his picture face down and calls him a hypocrite. Discuss the psychological progression that leads Manon to this thoroughgoing change of heart.

2. Manon recalls that as a child her father told her that "Religion was for the negroes," adding that "it was their solace and consolation, as they are ours" (p.22). Discuss this remark.

3. In what sense is Sarah an alter ego or a double for Manon?

4. Manon hears voices at several points in the novel, and they’re always saying things she can’t quite understand. Where do you think these voices are coming from?

5. This novel opens with a woman watching her husband through a spyglass. Is this a metaphor for what follows?

6. There are several scenes involving nursing in this novel. Manon suggests that the practice of sending babies out to be nursed by slaves is "how the poison entered us all" (p.180). What is this poison?

7. "It was the lie at the center of everything, the great lie we all supported, tended and worshipped as if our lives depended upon it…" (p.179). Manon claims that it is this lie that has turned her heart to stone, and not, as her aunt maintains, the burden of her childlessness. What, in your view, constitutes this lie?

8. When Manon is in her husband’s control, one might say that she is something of a slave herself. But once her husband is dead, she is perfectly free. What can explain the persistence of her sense of injustice and victimization?

9. Why does the author refuse to let Sarah tell the story of her failed escape from bondage herself? What could be the purpose of having these events related third hand, by the slave-catcher to an acquaintance and thence to Manon’s Aunt Lelia?

10. When Manon refuses to sell Sarah and Walter to Mr. Roget, she says the bit of white plaster that falls from his cuff onto the carpet spurs her decision, that it "enraged" her and, unbeknownst to Mr. Roget, "sealed his fate" (p.170). Is it really the reason Manon refuses to part with Sarah and Walter? Why does Mr. Roget’s offer make her so angry?

11. How does Manon really feel about Walter by the end of the novel? What do you imagine will become of him?