Skip to main content

Reading Group Guide

Discussion Questions

Good Girls Gone Bad: A Novel

1. Despite its comic overtones, Good Girls Gone Bad is a sincere portrait of a woman struggling to choose life over death. How is humor used throughout the book to underscore serious issues? Does Janey's ironic tone enhance or hinder the book's emotional depth?

2. Describe Janey Fabre. Is she as invisible to the world as she believes? How does her image of herself differ from other people's perception? Do most people see themselves as others do?

3. Janey is an unreliable narrator. How does her unwillingness -- or inability -- to tell the truth bear on her relationships with women and men? With her family? On the story itself? Should the girls have confronted her or were they right to let her get caught in her own lies? Could their betrayal be considered a good thing in light of how the story ends?

4. What role does actuarial science play in Good Girls Gone Bad? How is the metaphor of actuarial probability used?

5. Suicide and suicide ideation is explored at length in this novel. How does Janey's relationship with her mother bear on Janey's suicidal impulses? Janey's relationship with her father? Do you think self-destructive behavior is learned within a family?

6. American culture is obsessed with youth and beauty. What does Good Girls Gone Bad seem to be saying about women aging? Does it create a realistic portrait of how women over forty feel about themselves? Do you believe society is as harsh as the girls believe?

7. Why do the women in the book call themselves "girls?"

8. Good Girls Gone Bad has been described as a black comedy. What are the elements of a black comedy?

9. Look at the book's epigrams. To whom does the Elizabeth Bishop quote refer: "When you write my epitaph, you must say I was the loneliest woman who ever lived?" Janey? Janey's mother? The girls?

10. What do you think about how the men in the novel are portrayed? Tobias? Janey's dates? Her father? Does the book depict relationships between men and women realistically? If not, is this done on purpose?

Good Girls Gone Bad: A Novel
by Jillian Medoff

  • Publication Date: November 1, 2003
  • Paperback: 304 pages
  • Publisher: Avon A
  • ISBN-10: 0060936916
  • ISBN-13: 9780060936914