Skip to main content

Reading Group Guide

Discussion Questions

A Casualty of War: A Bess Crawford Mystery

1. A CASUALTY OF WAR takes place in 1918 as the Great War comes to an end, but soldiers and civilians alike are still struggling with unbearable losses and a changed England. Has reading this novel given you a new appreciation of the lasting wounds conflict leaves in its wake on all those involved?

2. Bess encounters many soldiers suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder, a condition that would not be fully acknowledged in the medical community until late in the twentieth century. What is your impression of the attitudes toward “shell shock” during the Great War, and the fates of the soldiers experiencing it?

3. Bess and Simon Brandon have known each other for many years and are very close.  Do you think her acceptance of him in the family --- she has said he is the son her father never had --- has made it difficult for her to see him in any other light? Should she? Is a romance between them necessary to the story? Or would it spoil the series?

4. Why do you think Bess feels so much responsibility to help Captain Travis? She feels guilty for mentioning his cousin while he is struggling to identify his assailant. But she also knew him beforehand, knew the man he was. Or is it seeing him tied to his bed in a windowless room? Perhaps it’s a need to find out what is really true?

5. Bess gently refuses Sergeant Lassiter’s proposal, insisting there is too much work to be done to consider herself. But as the Great War is ending, what do you think drove her most to decline his offer? She would have to resign from nursing if she said yes. Does that affect her decision? Should she have told him to wait?

6. The Armistice brings the fighting to a close. Why does Bess feel so strongly that her work isn’t done? She became a nursing Sister to save as many men as she could, and she has done that. Do you think this is true to the nursing profession, to stay on to help those who will never recover fully?

7. Has this series helped you understand the Great War, and the sacrifices that were made by so many both on the battlefield and on the home front? What were your views before you read these books? And after reading them?

8. What is your impression of Mrs. Travis’s character? Do you think it is unfair of her to hold the past against the Captain? What do you think drives her most to ignore her son’s wishes in the will?

9. Do you think Bess and Simon believe the fortune teller who explains the dream she has about James Travis? What do you make of her claim?

10. Did the identity of the killer surprise you? Whom did you most suspect throughout the novel, and why?

11. At the end of the novel, the world is on the precipice of massive change. And Bess too will eventually have to return to civilian life. What do you think lies in store for her next? What is there in her character that you believe will guide her toward the future?

A Casualty of War: A Bess Crawford Mystery
by Charles Todd